Frustrating afternoon in Dumfries after goalless draw

It was a frustrating afternoon in Dumfries as Queen of the South and Dunfermline played out a goalless draw. 

Gary Naysmith’s men had only lost 3 matched in all competitions this term while the Pars were hoping to avoid a third successive defeat.

Derek Lyle returned to the 18-man squad after missing out last weekend against Montrose but on-loan St Johnstone forward Chris Kane missed out through injury.

Callum Morris, Ryan Williamson and Fraser Aird returned from international duty to boost Allan Johnston’s squad as Joe Cardle, Michael Paton and David Hopkirk remained out injured. Dean Shiels began a 2-game suspension after his dismissal last weekend against Falkirk.

Queens’ top scorer Stephen Dobbie had the first chance of the encounter early on but his left footed shot went over the bar.

Dunfermline’s only chance of the first half was through a Nicky Clark effort but his attempt at goal from close range hit the side netting.

Lyndon Dykes, James McFadden and Dobbie again had efforts at goal as the hone side dominated proceedings.

Both sides would have hoped for better in the second half, and it was a more even contest in the second forty-five.

Industrious winger Kallum Higginbotham had the first shot at goal in the second half but his right-footed effort dribbled wide of Alan Martin’s goal, with the ex-Dumbarton goalkeeper still waiting for his first save of the contest.

He was, however, forced to work just moments later when 17-year-old Callum Smith curled an effort from the left of the box to the top right corner but the keeper was able to gather.

Then, from the next attack, the ball fell to Fordyce at the bank post but the former Dunfermline captain couldn’t capitalise on a great opportunity as the full-back prodded an effort at goal from 10 yards out but it was straight down the throat of Sean Murdoch.

Ryan Williamson caused problems down the right and when he swung in a teasing ball it looked like the opener would come through Declan McManus but the striker somehow missed from within the 6-yard box. It looked as if the ball was cleared by a defender as McManus stooped low but referee Stephen Finnie gave a goal kick.

Both sides pushed for the opener, which would surely be the winner, but it wasn’t to come.

Lee Ashcroft had a header cleared off the line before Dykes fired a left-footed shot into the arms of Murdoch.

The match ends the first quarter in the SPFL Ladbrokes Championship for both sides. The Pars will be the happier of the two sides I am sure with a marked improvement on last season’s opening quarter while Queens will rue another draw in a frustrating start to the season for the men from Palmerston Park.

Team Line-Ups

Queen of the South

1. Alan Martin

4. Callum Fordyce

15. Jason Kerr

5. Darren Brownlie

3. Jordan Marshall

17. Connor Murray (Andy Stirling 76′)

14. Kyle Jacobs

8. John Rankin (Captain) (Callum Tapping 87′)

16. James McFadden (Derek Lyle 72′)

11. Stephen Dobbie

25. Lyndon Dykes


20. Jack Leightfield (GK)

2. Shaun Rooney

6. Callum Tapping

7. Andy Stirling

9. Derek Lyle

18. Ross Fergusson

24. Scott Mercer


1. Sean Murdoch

2. Ryan Williamson

5. Callum Morris (Captain)

6. Lee Ashcroft

14. Jason Talbot

7. Kallum Higginbotham

13. Aaron Splaine

8. Nat Wedderburn

23. Callum Smith

9. Declan McManus

10. Nicky Clark


20. Cammy Gill (GK)

3. Lewis Martin

4. Jean-Yves M’Voto

16. Andy Ryan

17. Fraser Aird

18. Conner Duthie

19. Scott Lochhead

Revere; Stephen Finnie

Attendance: 1,834


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s